April 22, 2008

AI ~ top 6


~ The Music of Andrew Lloyd Webber~

Syesha Mercado ~ "One Rock & Roll Too Many" - I was thinking, "is that girl on TOP of the piano?? Merciful Heavens!" Ok, never heard of this song in my life but she looked amazing tonite! She did a great job with this and I totally agree with the judges that this Broadway/Theater is her niche.

Jason Castro ~ "Memories" - Ok, not too impressed tonite with this performance. I think it may be his turn to go. Sorry!

Brooke White ~ "You Must Love Me" - First, LOVED the dress...she looked wonderful! There was the little 'oops' in the beginning, I don't know what the right choice is to make whether to continue or stop. Seems like her nerves are just getting the better of her each night, I am not sure whether she would make it as the American Idol right now. That said, I think she is totally believable, real, and genuine...you just can't help but smile when she's on stage. Her emotion in the song was raw and this was a very tough song to sing. I still love her but I'm a little worried for her. VOTED. okay it was a bit of a sympathy vote.

David Archuletta ~ "Think of Me" - WOW!! LOVE this song in the Phantom and LOVED the arrangement he sang of it tonite! I thought it was one of his better performances. *Simon, WHAAAAT are you smokin'??*

Carly Smithson ~ "Superstar" - Uh....hmmmm....eh....'nuf said.

David Cook ~ "Music of the Night" - LOVE.LOVE.LOVE. this song!! Can I just say humina.humina.humina?? Whew, that was "LAVA.HOT"! Somebody call the Fire Department...David is ON.FIRE. I thought it was actually a nice change up for him tonite, really showed his multifaceted talent! VOTED.VOTED.VOTED. :D


BEST of the NIGHT:
is there any doubt?

if you ain't voting for him yet...then you better start!! He's my pick to win it...

6 comments:

Pajama Mama said...

Yikes!! I've been so busy reading everyone else's reviews that I FORGOT TO VOTE!!!!

David C was my fave too...so now, I must go vote for him.

Jeannie

theragan3 said...

I was waiting to hear your take on tonight to see if we agreed - on most we did. I liked Carly tonight and thought tht Syeshia was great as well... but my all time favorite was David Cook for sure. I pick him to win as well. Tomorrow night see if he reminds you of JD... I see David and see JD! Am I smoking something or what??
Love ya!
Rin

Jen said...

I gave a sympathy vote (make that 10) to Jason. Old habits die hard and although he didn't do as well tonight, I am hoping that he makes it another week. I'm slowly warming up to David C. He wasn't my favorite, but after last week's song (Mariah), I'm a fan.

Cindy Swanson said...

You are so right about David Cook...he continues to impress me more and more. He did an AMAZING job on "Music of the Night"! I love Jason and Brooke dearly, but I think one of them is going home tonight. :(

Tammy said...

David Cook has my vote too! I thinks it's gonna be the David's down to the wire!

Sarah said...

I Totally agree!!!! This guy is fantastic!

 
Restored 316 Designs